Prin, a professor and a Catholic, moves to small-town Indiana to work for an evangelical millionaire who's building a theme park inspired by Dante's Inferno. He soon becomes involved in the challenging lives of his co-workers and in the wider struggles of their opioid-ravaged community while trying to reconcile with his wife and God. When a Black teenager is killed, creationists, politicians, and protesters alike appear. In the midst of this American tumult, Prin risks everything to help the lost and angry souls around him while looking for his own way home.